Review: Iron Squad Vol. 2: Pacific Invasion

-
Iron Squad Vol. 2: Pacific Invasion Iron Squad Vol. 2: Pacific Invasion by Jean-Luc Sala
My rating: 3 of 5 stars

Rating 3 out of 5 | Grade : C; War of the World; 日本 edition

The second volume of Jean-Luc Sala's Iron Squad, leaves much to be desired. This volume which focuses on the fictional invasion of the US by a 'mecha'nized Imperial Japan, sees a ragtag group of recruits, who highjack a command mecha of the Japanese to try and mount an almost suicidal mission to help the Allies.



For one, the artwork of the story, which was the highlight of Volume 1, appear to be significantly watered down, and lacks the depth, richness & intensity as the original. There are a few panels which show promise, and I do appreciate the visuals of the Mechanized walkers treading the beaches in a mechapunk remake of the Invasion of Normandy. But it does fall short.



Second, the characters, which do appear as interesting in the onset, don't really do anything to me, even as they are being killed off in droves.

Third, the climax is a total asspull of contrivances, which makes you want to root for the Axis, even though they're supposed to be the bad guys. It feels unearned, even when (view spoiler)



Lastly, damn it was I miffed at not getting the same level of Mecha versus Mecha action we saw in the western frontier. By comparison, the engagements here were quite tame, and the walkers on either side going down like flies at the slightest damage.

And frankly, I expected more diversity when it came to the Imperial arsenal of walkers. All in all, an OK entry which needed more polish.


View all my reviews

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Review: Asterix and Obelix All at Sea

-
Image
Asterix and Obelix All at Sea by Albert Uderzo My rating: 3 of 5 stars I've noticed a dip in quality, be it regarding the biting humor, satire or puns in the past few Asterix stories, glaring as it was in Asterix and the Secret Weapon . As before, the story lacks a clear direction, mixing and matching elements such as a slave revolt aboard Caesar's ship with the discovery of the mythical Atlantis. These elements just don't seem to mesh well. Taken separately, 'Asterix & the slave revolt' & 'Asterix in Atlantis' could have been great standalone stories in its own right. Especially when you consider how topically the mythical island is described in the story. It lacked the satirical core, which made the initial Asterix stories entertaining. Anyway, onwards to the plot. There is a slave revolt aboard Caesar's flagship; The Greek Spartakis, has freed a band of multiethnic slaves and are currently fleeing from the
Read more

Review: ഓട്ടോറിക്ഷക്കാരൻ്റെ ഭാര്യ | Autorikshawkkarante Bharya

-
Image
ഓട്ടോറിക്ഷക്കാരൻ്റെ ഭാര്യ | Autorikshawkkarante Bharya by M. Mukundan My rating: 3 of 5 stars In a series of short stories, M. Mukundan, the eminent writer of Mayyazhi, paints for us the day to day, slice of life fictionalized tales of the people in everyday lives. The tales he composed range from OK, to good, to head scratching, to thought inducing, a full cornucopia. But sad to say, there isn’t much meat to these stories, a collected anthology from the stories he’d penned in various news publications. Mukundan himself seems the most soulful and engaging, when delving into the semi fictional tales that he crafts about his beloved Mayyazhi; with its colorful history and ever more colorful coterie of characters. Out of all the collections of stories which are printed here, the one which connected with me the most, is the one titled ‘Malayali Daivangal’ (Malayali Gods). The tale is about a French tourist couple that come to visit Mayyazhi and Kerala
Read more